The Legal Significance of Holding Deposits

  • The agreement to, and payment of, a holding deposit creates a legally binding contract between the landlord (or his agent) and the prospective tenant.
  • The contract is commonly called a holding deposit agreement, sometimes referred to as a HDA.
  • A HDA is a conditional contract, which grants the prospective tenant both the right and obligation to enter into the proposed tenancy provided the landlord (or his agent) can verify the information provided by the prospective tenant is correct.
  • The conditions of the contract can be oral or written, or both. If written, the conditions will be in a document typically referred to as a holding deposit agreement, reservation agreement or proposal to let.
  • The conditions of the contract should stipulate the key terms of the tenancy such as the type of tenancy, names of landlord(s) and tenant(s), address of property to be let, initial period of the tenancy including commencement date, amount of rent, amount of tenancy deposit (sometimes referred to as core terms) and specially negotiated terms such as a break clause (sometimes referred to as special conditions).
  • Neither party to the contract may insist on the conditions of the contract or the terms of the proposed tenancy being  varied or ‘renegotiated.’ An attempt to do so would ordinarily amount to repudiation of the contract, entitling the innocent party to remedies under contract law. The contract marks the conclusion of negotiations not the starting point. Even if a prospective tenant accepts and signs the landlord’s variations to the tenancy agreement, the new terms contrary to the HDA may not be enforceable for lack of consideration.
  • A holding deposit is not a tenancy deposit and is not subject to the statutory tenancy deposit protection scheme, although it will typically be paid towards the first payment of rent under the tenancy, or towards the payment of the tenancy deposit in respect of the tenancy.
  • A HDA is not a tenancy it is an agreement for tenancy – a conditional contract, which grants the applicant the right (and obligation) to enter into the proposed tenancy, subject to conditions, and it satisfies the requirements of the offer, acceptance, and consideration in the form of the holding deposit payment. HDAs are thus governed by contract law, not by residential tenancy legislation.
  • HDAs should be more significant to the parties’ interests than the final tenancy agreement and they record the key terms and are the basis for entering into the tenancy. Detailed standard form tenancy terms are subject to statutory restrictions and regulatory oversight.
  • The tenancy agreement should not deviate from the agreed HDA terms.
  • At any one time a tenant should only pay one holding deposit in respect of one property and should decline other proposals in the interim. Conversely at any one time a landlord (or his agent) should only accept one holding deposit in respect of one property and should decline other proposals in the interim.
  • The Property Ombudsman, Code of Practice for Residential Letting Agents requires agents provide both parties with a draft or specimen tenancy agreement prior to the prospective tenant becoming liable for a holding deposit associated with the rental of the property except where such opportunity is declined or where the agent holds an instruction to the contrary.
  • The HDA can only be cancelled if the landlord is prohibited by section 22 of the Immigration Act 2014 (persons disqualified by immigration status) from granting a tenancy of the housing to the prospective tenant or the prospective tenant provides false or misleading information to the landlord.
  • The legal significance of a HDA needs to be emphasised to landlords and prospective tenants and that both parties at the outset that payment of a holding deposit creates a legally binding contract. Tenancy applicants should be provided a draft copy of the tenancy agreement before any HDA is created. Landlords need to be made aware that if the conditions of the contract are satisfied, they cannot “renegotiate” the terms of the lease after a HDA has been agreed.
Posted in Landlords | Leave a comment

Understanding and addressing damp and mould for landlords

On 7th September 2023 the UK government issued guidance on damp and mould in rented accommodation. The guidance is 56 pages long, not including linked references, and there are 185 occurrences of the word ‘landlord’. This article provides a summary of what it is landlords should be doing regarding damp and mould in their properties.

The guidance can be found here: Understanding and addressing the health risks of damp and mould in the home

Preventative

  • Have clear processes in place to document, manage and act on reports of damp and mould and to identify common issues and trends in your housing.
  • Understand the condition of your homes and use this to adopt a preventative approach to dealing with damp and mould, making the necessary interventions to ventilation, energy efficiency and building deficiencies before damp and mould occur.
  • Understand that some homes are more difficult to heat, either due to their energy efficiency or cost of living pressures, and that this can make damp and mould more likely to occur.
  • Consider what support you can provide or signpost tenants to.
  • Support tenants to understand what they can do to reduce damp and mould, where applicable and appropriate. This must never be a substitute for addressing the underlying causes of damp and mould.
  • Build relationships with health and social care and other frontline professionals supporting tenants to ensure that every opportunity to identify tenants living in homes with damp and mould is utilised, ‘making every contact count.’
  • Ensure staff and any external contractors are aware of the significant health risks associated with damp and mould, the need to address the underlying causes of the issue and not just remove visible mould, are aware of any processes associated with reporting and addressing damp and mould and understand the importance of being sensitive to tenants’ circumstances and vulnerabilities.
  • Build relationships with tenants, ensuring that tenants feel encouraged to report damp and mould.

Reactive

  • Ensure that the accommodation is free from damp and mould and identify and address the underlying causes of any damp and mould problems.
  • Respond to reports of damp and mould.
  • In response to any report of damp and mould, inspect the home to assess the issue and identify and tackle the underlying causes of damp and mould with urgency.
  • Inform the tenant about the steps that will be taken to remove any mould and address any underlying causes and the timeframes for the work.
  • Prior to the removal of any mould, photograph, and document the location of the mould, to help identify the source.
  • Remove any mould using a qualified professional when appropriate.
  • Advise any tenant who is concerned about the symptoms they are experiencing to consult a healthcare professional.
  • Inspect the home at least 6 weeks after any remedial work has been carried out, to ensure that the issue has been fixed and damp and mould have not reappeared. If damp and mould have reappeared, further investigation and intervention should be pursued.

Additional guidance covers:

  • Processes to report and monitor damp and mould
  • Property condition monitoring
  • Guidance for individual landlords with a small number of properties and for housing providers
  • Training internal staff and external contractors
  • Collaborative working with other professionals for the social and private rented sectors
  • Building relationships with tenants

External Checks

  • damaged or blocked pipes, gutters or downpipes
  • broken seals around windows or ill-fitting windows that do not close fully
  • visible structural or facade defects, such as cracks in render or the foundation, missing or broken roof finishes
  • bridged (compromised) damp proof course

Internal Checks

  • peeling wallpaper
  • visible damp or staining
  • visible condensation
  • defective plaster
  • consistently high relative humidity, as assessed using a moisture meter or environmental monitors
  • low levels of loft or wall insulation
  • low internal wall temperature
  • damaged, blocked, absent or switched off mechanical ventilation (for example, extractors in kitchens and bathrooms)
  • ineffective or broken heating systems

Ventilation Checklist

  • Do kitchens have ventilation systems (for example, extractor fans, cooker hoods) that are fully operational and sufficiently powered to remove moisture from cooking?
  • Do bathrooms have ventilation systems (for example extractor fans) that are fully operational and sufficiently powered to remove moisture from showering and bathing?
  • Do tenants know how to use ventilation systems and are they making use of them?
  • Can windows be opened and are tenants making use of them?
  • Do windows have trickle vents and are these kept open and free from blockages?
  • Do tenants understand what they can do to improve ventilation and moisture control?
  • Do tenants have access to secure spaces to dry laundry outdoors?
  • Are roof and under floor spaces properly ventilated to ensure timber remains dry?

Heating checklist

  • Is the home energy efficient?
  • Is the heating system (including radiators) working effectively, sufficiently powered for the property and are tenants able to control it?
  • Has the tenant been given clear, written instructions on how to use the heating system most effectively?
  • Are the occupants struggling to heat their home?
Posted in Landlords | Leave a comment

Can you pass responsibility for a breach to your sub-tenant?

In Dorrington Residential Limited v 56 Clifton Gardens Limited, Dorrington were the long leaseholder and 57 Clifton Gardens were the landlord.The long lease leaseholder had sub-tenants.

The landlord served the long leaseholders notice within the terms of the lease to inspect the property. The landlord was unable to get access and the long leaseholder was liable for the resulting breach.

Lesson Learnt

1.The long leaseholder is responsible for the covenants in the lease and they cannot be passed on to the sub-tenant.

2. Ensure notices are served in accordance with lease or s.196 Law of Property Act 1925

Posted in Landlords | Leave a comment

How does the revised Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005 affect fire risk assessments?

Where a building contains two or more sets of domestic premises a fire risk assessment must now include an assessment of:

* Building’s structure
* External walls
* Any common parts
* Doors between the domestic premises and common parts.

Further Reading

Article 6 of The Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005

Posted in Landlords | Leave a comment

What landlords need to do to comply with the new (2022) fire safety regulations

The Fire Safety Act 2021 came into force on 16 May 2022 and amends the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005.

The Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005 now applies where a building contains two or more domestic premises and applies to:

(a) the building’s structure and external walls and any common parts;

(b) all doors between the domestic premises and common parts

Reference to external walls now includes:

(a) doors or windows in those walls, and

(b) anything attached to the exterior of those walls (including balconies).

Where this has obvious application is for responsible persons (e.g., landlords or managing agents) of buildings containing two or more domestic premises risk assessing the building.

The Fire Safety (England) Regulations 2022 comes into force on 23rd January 2023.

The responsible person, in relation to a building which contains two or more sets of domestic premises and which contains common parts through which residents would need to evacuate in the case of an emergency, must display required information in a conspicuous part of the building and provide the required information to the residents of the building.

The required information is:

  • Fire safety instructions

I.            instructions relating to the evacuation strategy for the building;

II.         instructions as regards how to report a fire to the fire and rescue authority;

III.         any other instruction that tells residents what they must do when a fire has occurred.

  • Fire Doors

I.            fire doors should be kept shut when not in use;

II.          residents or their guests should not tamper with the self-closing devices;

III.         residents should report any faults or damages with doors immediately to the responsible person.

The responsible person must provide the required information:

(a) to a new resident of domestic premises within the building, as soon as reasonably practicable after that resident moves into the premises;

(b) to all residents of domestic premises within the building within each period of 12 months beginning with 23rd January 2023.

After any material changes to the fire safety instructions, the responsible person must display the fire safety instructions and provide a copy to residents.

For buildings over 11 metres and buildings over 18 metres or more than seven storeys (classed as high rise) the requirements of the regulations are different.

Further Reading

Fire Safety Act 2021
The Fire Safety (England) Regulations 2022

Posted in Landlords | Leave a comment

Electrical Safety Standards Regulations 2020 – In a Nutshell

The Electrical Safety Standards in the Private Rented Sector (England) Regulations 2020 come into force on 1st June 2020 and apply to all new tenancies from 1st July 2020 and all existing tenancies from 1st April 2021.

Overview

Landlords must ensure that the standards for electrical installations in the eighteenth edition of the Wiring Regulations are met during any period when the residential premises are occupied under a tenancy.

First Inspection and Testing

For new tenancies (including renewals), the first inspection and test must be carried out before the tenancy commences. For existing tenancies, the first inspection and test must be carried out by 1st April 2021.

Inspection and Testing Intervals

Inspection and testing must be carried out at intervals of no more than 5 years or where the most recent inspection and test report requires inspection and testing to be at intervals of less than 5 years, at the intervals specified in that report.

Inspection and Test Reports

Landlords must:

• Obtain a report from the person conducting the inspection and test;
• Supply a copy of that report to each existing tenant of the premises within 28 days of the inspection and test;
• Supply a copy of that report to the local housing authority within 7 days of receiving a request in writing for it from that authority;
• Retain a copy of that report until the next inspection and test is due and supply a copy to the person carrying out the next inspection and test;
• Supply a copy of the most recent report to any new tenant before the tenant occupies the premises;
• Supply a copy of the most recent report to any prospective tenant (1) within 28 days of receiving a request in writing for it.

Remedial Work

Where an inspection and test report indicates that an installation does not meet or potentially does not meet the standards for electrical installations in the eighteenth edition of the Wiring Regulations and the report requires further investigative or remedial work, landlords must (2):

• Ensure that the investigative or remedial work is carried out within 28 days or the period specified in the report if less than 28 days, starting with the date of the inspection and testing.
• Obtain written confirmation from a qualified person that the further investigative or remedial work has been carried out and that the standards for electrical installations in the eighteenth edition of the Wiring Regulations are met or further investigative or remedial work is required.
• Supply that written confirmation, together with a copy of the report which required the further investigative or remedial work to each existing tenant of the residential premises within 28 days of completion of the further investigative or remedial work;
• Supply that written confirmation, together with a copy of the report which required the further investigative or remedial work to the local housing authority within 28 days of completion of the further investigative or remedial work.
• Where further investigative work is carried out is that further investigative or remedial work is required, the must repeat the steps above in respect of that further investigative or remedial work.

1. A prospective tenant is a person who requests information about the premises, makes a request to view the premises or makes an offer to rent those premises.
2. According to the UK government guide for landlords, further remedial work is not required for observations with Classification Code C3.

Further Reading

The Electrical Safety Standards in the Private Rented Sector (England) Regulations 2020
Guide for landlords: electrical safety standards in the private rented sector

Posted in Landlords, Tenants | Leave a comment

Assured Shorthold Tenancy Tenants’ Notice to Quit – Is it valid?

Common Law

  • * The minimum period for a notice to quit is a complete period of the tenancy
  • * The notice period must end on the last day of a period of the tenancy
  • * A notice that expires on the first day of a period of the tenancy has the same effect as a notice ending on the previous day


Statute

  • * A notice must be in writing
  • * A notice must be given not less than 4 weeks before the date on which it is to take effect


Case Law

  • * If the period of the tenancy is longer than 4 weeks, the notice period is equivalent to the period of the tenancy, except for yearly periodic tenancies where the notice period is six months
  • * Once served a notice cannot be withdrawn
  • * In calculating the notice period, the day on which a notice is served is included but the last day referred to in the notice is not. For example, a notice served on a Tuesday that expires on a Tuesday four weeks later would comply with the four weeks’ notice requirement.
  • * A notice must expire on either the first or last day of a period of the tenancy. For example, a notice served on the first of a month to end a monthly tenancy that began on the first of January could expire on the first day of a whole period of the tenancy, i.e. the first of February. It could not expire on the last day of the period, i.e 31 January, because that would not constitute a full monthly period of notice (it would be short by one day).
  • * A notice that includes an appropriately worded ‘savings clause’ will be valid


Editors Note: There is no rule of law that requires a tenant to give notice to end a fixed term tenancy. The now withdrawn guidance on unfair terms in tenancy agreements published by the Office of Fair Trading in September 2005 stated:


A fixed term tenancy comes to an end when the fixed term runs out and a tenant does not have to give notice to end it.


The guidance implied any clauses requiring a tenant to give notice to end a fixed term tenancy is a misleading termination clause.


The same guidance objects to terms that impose a contractual obligation on the tenant to give notice in order for the tenancy to be terminated at the end of the fixed term.


Editors Note: We are not aware this particular guidance has ever been tested in court. The same guidance suggests landlords should serve a notice requiring possession if they want to make it clear they want to end the tenancy at the end of the fixed term. This is not a very elegant solution. Aside from the complexities of such notices it would create uncertainty for the tenants having been served with a ‘sword of Damocles’ notice so early in a tenancy. A tenant notifying the Landlord they plan to end the tenancy at the end of the fixed term is a reasonable courtesy.


Contract


* A tenancy agreement may require the tenant to give a longer period of notice.

Posted in Landlords, Tenants | Leave a comment

The unintended consequences of the Tenant Fees Act on lets with pets

Almost 12 million households in the UK own a pet so you could question why a landlord would exclude such a large proportion of the population by stipulating ‘no pets’ when they advertise their property for rent.

Traditionally many landlords have recognised how widespread pet ownership is and how tenants with pets can make good long-term tenants. Pets are often welcomed by landlords subject to certain conditions including payment of a higher deposit and an agreement that the tenant would have the carpets professionally cleaned at the end of the tenancy.

The arrival of the Tenant Fees Act on 1st June 2019 is a game-changer and is likely to have a negative effect on tenants with pets. Three parts of the Act that will have an effect on tenancies with pets are:

1. Tenancy Deposits are now capped at 5 weeks rent – landlords can no longer require a tenant pays a tenancy deposit higher than 5 weeks rent.

2. A landlord must not require the tenant enters into a contract for the provision of a service with a third party in connection with a tenancy – landlords can no longer require a tenant to enter into a contract with a vet, pest controller or cleaner.

3. A landlord must not require the tenant enters into a contract for insurance with a third party in connection with a tenancy – landlords can no longer require a tenant to have tenant liability insurance or third party liability insurance for their pet.

Likely Outcome

1. Landlords are less likely to let their property to tenants with pets – the changes the Act brings will be perceived to expose landlords to higher risk and cost so many landlords will simply advertise their properties as ‘no pets’. For those landlords who never welcomed tenants with pets their stance will harden and more than ever these landlords will refuse to consider tenants with pets.

2. Higher rents – of those landlords who welcomed pets in the past many (but not all) will continue to do so ‘subject to negotiation’ and landlords will expect tenants with pets to offer and pay a higher rent to cover three things:

• Treating the property for fleas and other parasites at the end of the tenancy
• Cleaning the flooring and soft furnishings at the end of the tenancy
• Additional rent in lieu of the additional tenancy deposit (pet deposit) previously collected to cover any damage caused by the pet

A few points of note on this:

• 9% of the UK population have a pet allergy. 1 in 4 cats and 1 in 7 dogs are carrying fleas, and about 11 per cent of these fleas are infected with potentially pathogenic bacteria (Bartonella). For the sake of the health of the next occupier of their property landlords can only hope, but cannot require, outgoing tenants will treat the property for fleas and other parasites and clean the flooring and soft furnishings so will need to take responsibility for this. The only way to legally recover the cost of this is to charge tenants with pets a higher rent.

• The cost of the flea treatment and cleaning will reasonably need to be collected during the term certain for the tenancy (fixed term of the tenancy). Under the Act landlords cannot charge a higher rent for a period at the start of the tenancy and reduce the rent for a later period in the tenancy. The larger the property and the shorter the fixed term, the higher the premium will be and with most tenancies continuing beyond the fixed term, tenants with pets will ultimately be paying more in increased rent than the cost of the fees they paid before the Act became law. Good news for landlords, bad news for tenants with pets.

• Landlords will need to ensure, and make it clear, tenants are paying a ‘higher rent’ and not a ‘pet fee’ or ‘pet deposit’ as these fees or deposits are prohibited under the Act.

• Section 13 rent increases during a tenancy for which a tenant is paying a premium rent could prove to be awkward as tenants could challenge the increase on the grounds that the rent is unreasonable and a rent above market value may be considered unreasonable by a tribunal. A possible workaround for landlords is to include a rent review clause in the tenancy agreement. Rent review clauses apply to fixed term tenancies and contractual periodic tenancies only.

Further Reading

1 in 4 cats and 1 in 7 dogs carrying fleas with high levels of bacteria, finds Big Flea Project (Bristol University)

Posted in Landlords, Tenants | Leave a comment

What payments are landlords and letting agents permitted to take from tenants on or after 1st June 2019?

1. Rent

2. Tenancy Deposit – maximum five weeks’ rent where the annual rent in respect of the tenancy immediately after its grant, renewal or continuance is less than £50,000, or six weeks’ rent, where the annual rent in respect of the tenancy immediately after its grant, renewal or continuance is £50,000 or more.

3. Holding Deposit – maximum one week’s rent.

4. Payment in the event of a default – for the loss of a key to, or other security device giving access to, the housing to which the tenancy relates pay the costs which are reasonably incurred by the Landlord or his Agent as a result of the default. {my understanding from this is that ‘security device giving access’ is a fob or card – sometimes called proximity devices}

5. Payment in the event of a default – for the failure to make a payment of rent in full before the end of the period of 14 days beginning with the date (“the due date”) on which the payment is required to be made in accordance with the tenancy agreement pay the aggregate of the amounts found by applying, in relation to each day after the due date for which the rent remains unpaid, an annual percentage rate of 3% above the Bank of England base rate to the amount of rent that remains unpaid at the end of that day.

6. Payment of damages for breach of a tenancy agreement or an agreement between a letting agent and a relevant person

7. On variation, assignment or novation of a tenancy at the tenant’s request pay the greatest of £50 and the reasonable costs of the person to whom the payment is to be made in respect of the variation, assignment or novation of the tenancy.

8. On termination of a tenancy at the tenant’s request in the case of a fixed term tenancy, before the end of the term, or in the case of a periodic tenancy, without the tenant giving the period of notice required under the tenancy agreement or by virtue of any rule of law pay the Landlord the loss suffered by the Landlord and pay his Agent the reasonable costs of the Agent for arranging the termination of a tenancy.

9. Payment in respect of council tax

10. Payment in respect of utilities

11. Payment in respect of a television licence

12. Payment in respect of communication services

A Landlord or Agent taking any other payments from a Tenant on or after 1st June 2019 in consideration of the grant, renewal, continuance, variation, assignment, novation or termination of a tenancy are prohibited.

Posted in Landlords, Tenants | Leave a comment

Can a letting agent represent a landlord in court?

Only ‘authorised persons’ e.g. solicitors and barristers are permitted to represent someone in court. If the letting agent is an authorised person then they could of course represent the landlord in court. With leave of the court a letting agent who is not an authorised person could attend a court hearing in the following situations:

  • If the landlord is a company, the company can appoint a syndic to represent it
  • As a witness
  • As a McKenzie Friend (sometimes referred to as a next friend)

It is entirely at the discretion of the judge whether they ‘hear’ a person who is not an authorised person so it cannot and should not be relied on.

Non-authorised persons should not sign any forms in connection with litigation on behalf of the litigant (the landlord) and landlords and letting agents should consider carefully what activity the letting agent’s indemnity insurance covers in legal situations.

Posted in Landlords | Leave a comment